50 replies to this topic

[Evilspacecow]

I actually just watched all 4 seasons.  Really, really enjoying it.

 

I really love Rumpelstiltskin and Hook.

 

Some random annoyances though.  Why does Emma's "Super Power" of telling when someone is lying seem to only come into effect if it is needed for the story (and it is also completely forgotten in the first couple of season when some pretty big lies were told to her and she did not call anyone out).

 

Another thing that annoyed me on Season 4 was how all side characters got dropped completely until the fairy tale "Heroes and Villains" episodes at the very very end of the season.  I was enjoying a lot of the side things that were going on.

 

 

 

Ok, random prediction for season 5.  Rumple clearly has no power now.  At some point he is going to have the chance to get the dark one's powers back but will give it up for Belle.

[fluffy-rabbid]

Oh there is no way rumples is gonna give that up lol his my fav

 

[missauru]

Welcome to the chat/addiction!!!

 

As you saw in the last season Emma was sensing lies left and right but refused to believe that her parents would lie to her so ignored her "power". Maybe that is why? Or maybe it is just bad writing lol, many shows fall victim to those kinds of plot holes that are left and forgotten.

 

As for Rumple, I dont even know what will happen. For me, a lot of his appeal is the fact that he just cant help being bad. Even finding his true love doesnt stop it. So if they just change that completely I am not sure how I will feel. He has been my favorite since the beginning and Im not sure I could take such a drastic change. I know he will have to change now because of his darkness being gone but I hope he is still... himself. If they change him too drastically it becomes Beauty and her Prince. That is not the story I want to read! Also, wont he still know how to spin straw into gold? Not powerless!!!

[fluffy-rabbid]

Yeah Rumples got to turn evil or be plotting again imo I mean his lost a lot, Im not sure belle can change that he was dark with her even though he said he wouldn't lol

 

And yeah Emma's super power isn't really the lying thing, Its more the white or good  power

[missauru]

He was just asking why her lie detection skills only come into play when it is convenient  

[fluffy-rabbid]

yeah I just mean think they realised that one was kind of dumb once they gave her magic and no one was buying it lol

[missauru]

Yeah we can just blame it on the writing I guess 

[Evilspacecow]

Finally able to watch the first two episodes.
I really hate Emma's monotone talking now that she is evil. It is driving me crazy.

I am liking how after I (and probably many others) complained how the side characters disappeared how they came back and even called out that they hadn't been in the show.

At first I thought that the "dark swan" was really Zelena in disguise since I don't think she came back from Camelot but the dagger at the end of the 2nd episode still had Emma's name.

[Roughdawg4]

Yeah I thought it might be Zelena as well, but has she even been shown after Camelot?

[Evilspacecow]

Yeah I thought it might be Zelena as well, but has she even been shown after Camelot?

Not unless she was shown briefly at the dinner when they got back and I missed her.  So something happened to her.

[fluffy-rabbid]

She might be relocked up, just watched 3rd ep

[missauru]

Im guessing she was locked right back up when they returned. If she was missing we would have heard about it by now. Plus the sonogram thing would make no sense if she was gone

[fluffy-rabbid]

Thought it was a pretty good show this week

[Roughdawg4]

Yeah I want to see more of where this storyline is heading.

[missauru]

I think its starting out very slowly. Really cant wait for things to pick up, which you know they will

[missauru]

Things are picking up! If I didnt already love Merida this past ep would have done it. She is just great imo!!

 

Gotta love the flip they did with Emma and Rumple. I am excited to see if he can really be the hero they all need 

 

How do you guys feel about the actor they chose for Merlin?

[Roughdawg4]

Merida is coming in more so that's awesome. I love the flip but I am wondering where it is going.

even though Emma has the appearance of evil I still feel like she thinks she is doing what is right

[missauru]

I agree about Emma thinking what she is doing is right. Isnt that just the warped way the Dark One thinks though? I mean she justified tearing out a young girls heart to break her sons because it was "the only way". That is some messed up logic right there.

[Roughdawg4]

Yeah never thought about it like that but yeah most dark ones might feel they are doing the right thing

I wonder where they are going with the sword and what happens when the 2 pieces are reunited. I do find it odd that a piece of the sword is pure darkness

[Roughdawg4]

I thought with a 2 hour episode we would have more answers but I have more questions

minor gripe because the episodes were awesome