The Wolf Among Us ~ Trophy Guide & Roadmap by AnnMaRou
Overview
Estimated Trophy Difficulty: 1/10
Approximate Time To 100%: 6 ~ 7 hrs (min~max)
Trophy Breakdown: 36 Total
- Offline: 36 ( 25
, 5 
, 5 
, 1 
) - Online: None
Number of Playthroughs Needed: 1 +chapter select
Missable Trophies: None
Glitched Trophies: None
Are There Any Unobtainable Trophies: No
Does Difficulty Affect Trophies: N/A
Do Cheat Codes Disable Trophies: N/A
Are Peripherals Required: No
Online-Pass Required: No
Introduction
We all know in fairy tales they all lived happily ever after but when the last page of the book is turned and children go to sleep the fables continue on and their lives just like ours are filled with struggle and anguish. To live among humans, citizens of Fabletown need to disguise themselves by use of glamour, a government regulated magical substance that doesn't come cheap and not every fable can afford it. This state of affairs creates a very shady side to the fairy tale and as Bigby, sheriff of the fable community, you need to venture and uncover the darkest truth that lies underneath it all - who really is The Big Bad wolf among them.
Roadmap
Step 1: Story Playthrough
There are two ways you can approach this step:
- Play through the story, don't even read the guide, feel free to make whatever choices you like and enjoy the game without worrying about picking up missable Books of Fables because later you can collect them all by replaying specific chapters.
- If you're interested in the quickest way to obtain platinum, play through the story armed with information provided in this guide to pick up as many missable Books of Fables on the way and to minimise amount of times you will need to replay specific chapters.
At the end of this step you will have collected all story related trophies.
Step 2: Clean up
Whichever path you had chosen in Step 1 you will need to replay (rewind) several chapters at least once because each of the options given to Bigby are mutually exclusive but reward with a Book of Fables entry and cannot be obtained in one playthrough of a chapter.
As you play you can rewind a chapter right away or you can wait until you've played through the whole story - it's up to you.
You can check which Books of Fables you are missing by either looking in the Main Menu -> Extras -> Books of Fables or while in the Pause Menu -> Books of Fables.
To replay a chapter while in the Main Menu choose Play then pick relevant episode and a chapter, choose 
Rewind option and when the game asks you for a choice of a save file make sure to pick an empty slot or any save file that is not your current save file as it will overwrite your progress.
For details on how to obtain all Books of Fables please see Novice Librarian, Apprentice Librarian, Journeyman Librarian, Master Librarian and Grand Master Librarian.
Guide
Full Moon
Earned every Trophy in every episode of The Wolf Among Us.
Congratulations on the new shiny!
Episode 1
Welcome to Fabletown
Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 1.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Wolf in Sheriff's Clothing
Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 1.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There is one missable Book of Fables in this chapter. For details see Novice Librarian trophy description.
The Long Goodbye
Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 1.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
The Frog or the Prince?
Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 1.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Panic in the Parlours
Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 1.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
A Light Snowfall
Completed Episode 1: "Faith"
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
One Book of Fable will require you to rewind this chapter. For details see Novice Librarian trophy description.
Novice Librarian
Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 1.
Books of Fables:
Chapter 1 - none missable
Chapter 2 - When you get to Bigby's apartment look on the desk and read Bluebeard's file to unlock Bluebeard entry
Chapter 3 - none missable
Chapter 4 - none missable
Chapter 5 - none missable
Chapter 6 - You will need to play this chapter twice. When Bigby fights Grendel you will be given two choices: Walk away (rewards with Bigby's Mercy entry) or Tear off his arm (rewards with Bigby's Vengeance entry). After you pick one option and obtain respective Book of Fables rewind the chapter and then choose the other option.
Episode 2
Right to an Attorney
Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 2.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
Breaking Point
Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 2.
Story related and cannot be missed.
There are two missable Books of Fables in this chapter and their acquisition strictly depends on choices you make during interrogation event. For details see Apprentice Librarian trophy description.
Sisters
Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 2.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Made Them Cry
Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 2.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Can I Get a Fresh Set of Towels?
Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 2.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
No Respect for the Dead
Completed Episode 2: "Smoke and Mirrors"
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
Apprentice Librarian
Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 2.
Books of Fables:
Chapter 1 - no entries
Chapter 2 - You will need to play this chapter twice. Regardless of who you decided to apprehend in Chapter 1, during interrogation event play either 'good' or 'bad' cop.
- Good cop - for Bluebeard's Mercy entry use only conversation options, do not hit the suspect at any point, offer him a drink/cigarette when he asks to. When Bluebeard intervenes choose option to grab him and complete the QTE.
- Bad cop - for Ichabod's Denial entry be aggressive during the interrogation, hit the suspect at any opportunity that presents itself, burn him with a cigarette/cigar. When Crane intervenes tell him to back off.
As you conduct the interrogation notice in the top left corner a message 'You got Dee/Woody talking' pop up, it means your actions were successful and it has to appear four times for the interrogation to conclude.
Chapter 3 - none missable
Chapter 4 - none missable
Chapter 5 - no entries
Chapter 6 - no entries
Episode 3
Promising Leads
Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 3.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
Belly Full of Stones
Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 3.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There is one missable Book of Fables in this chapter. For details see Journeyman Librarian trophy description.
Story related and cannot be missed.
What Big Eyes You Have
Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 3.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like but at the end of the chapter make sure to pick Crane's Office as the next location for Bigby to go to in order to pick up missable Books of Fables in Chapter 4. For details see Journeyman Librarian trophy description.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Huff and Puff
Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 3.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
Provided at the end of Chapter 3 you picked to visit Crane's Office first there are three missable Book of Fables in this chapter. For details see Journeyman Librarian trophy description.
Severe Case of Lycanthropy
Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 3.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
One Book of Fable will require you to rewind this chapter. For details see Journeyman Librarian trophy description.
The Enchanted Land of New York City
Completed Episode 3: "A Crooked Mile"
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Journeyman Librarian
Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 3.
Books of Fables:
Chapter 1 - no entries
Chapter 2 - When Bigby arrives at the funeral ceremony choose option to Wait and go left over to the table. Investigate the notes until Troll Funeral Rights entry unlocks.
Chapter 3 - none missable, make sure to pick Crane's Office for Bigby to go to.
Chapter 4 - At Crane's Office while looking around find Crane's desk and investigate Headless Horseman statue to unlock Headless Horseman entry. Go to Dee & Dum's Office next where you will discover that Bluebeard trashed the place and after short conversation with Flycatcher which awards you with you Flycatcher entry you will automatically leave for The Trip Trap Bar.
At The Trip Trap Bar eventually you will find Lily's things guarded by doped up Holly. Make sure not to wake her up. Instead move a crate of bottles and Holly will shift her arm away allowing you to inspect contents of the box. Investigate small notebook for The Trip Trap Bar entry.
Chapter 5 - You will need to play this chapter twice. At Auntie Greenleaf's Bigby will be given two choices: obey Snow and Burn the tree (rewards with Glamour Tree entry) or disobey Snow and Spare the tree (rewards with Glamour Tube entry). After you pick one option and obtain respective Book of Fable rewind the chapter and then choose the other option.
Chapter 6 - none missable
Episode 4
Once Upon a Time
Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 4.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
There Was a Wolf
Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 4.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like but at the end of the chapter make sure to pick The Lucky Pawn as the next location for Bigby to go to in order to pick up missable Books of Fables in Chapter 3. For details see Master Librarian trophy description.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
Who Ruled The Land
Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 4.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
Provided at the end of Chapter 2 you picked to visit The Lucky Pawn there is one missable Book of Fables in this chapter. For details see Master Librarian trophy description.
He Was Much Feared
Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 4.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
But Soon He Mended His Evil Ways
Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 4.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
And All Were Happy
Completed Episode 4: "In Sheep's Clothing"
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Master Librarian
Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 4.
Books of Fables:
Chapter 1 - none missable
Chapter 2 - no entries, make sure to pick The Lucky Pawn for Bigby to go to.
Chapter 3 - At The Lucky Pawn make sure to first inspect the pin cushion in a glass case on the right side to obtain Briar Rose entry. If you inspect the leftmost glass case before anything else you will miss the entry and will have to replay the chapter.
Chapter 4 - none missable
Chapter 5 - none missable
Chapter 6 - none missable
Episode 5
Beginning of the End
Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 5.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
This House of Straw
Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 5.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
A Silver Bullet
Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 5.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There is one missable Book of Fables in this chapter. For details see Grand Master Librarian trophy description.
My Last Cigarette
Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 5.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no Books of Fables in this chapter.
The North Wind Blows
Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 5.
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Happily Ever After
Completed Episode 5: "Cry Wolf"
Story related and cannot be missed.
Play through the chapter making whatever choices you like.
There are no missable Books of Fables in this chapter.
Grand Master Librarian
Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 5.
Books of Fables:
Chapter 1 - no entries
Chapter 2 - no entries
Chapter 3 - In Sheppard Metalworks Bigby will be confronted by Bloody Mary. When she says 'Aw, he doesn't want to play' pick any conversational option to unlock Winter Wolf entry. Do not choose to hit her or you will have to replay the chapter.
Chapter 4 - no entries
Chapter 5 - none missable
Chapter 6 - none missable
