I forgot to post this up at the time but talking with Lord Raiden made me remember this. Make sure to use each of the 4 save files for each of the 4 fishers in the game for world mode. When I completed with all 4 characters the trophy did not pop. When I went to the files, I saw 3 out of the were complete while 1 of them was at the final match so I did not let it save at the end.
You do not want to fuck up this step because it will cost you 6-8 hours for each save.